Having an insurance claim denied can leave you facing unexpected expenses at a time when you may already be dealing with property damage, an accident, or another significant loss. Insurers must assess claims against the policy terms and applicable law, but a rejection does not always mean you have no options. Depending on the circumstances, you may be able to challenge the decision, request an internal review or escalate the dispute. Experienced insurance lawyers in Brisbane can help you understand the reasons for a refusal and identify the next steps.
This article explains why claims are denied, how to dispute an insurer’s decision in Queensland and when legal advice may help.
Why Do Insurance Companies Deny Claims?
Insurance claims can be rejected for several reasons, and not every refusal is necessarily justified. Sometimes, the insurer identifies a genuine exclusion. In other cases, the decision may depend on disputed evidence or an interpretation of the policy that the policyholder does not agree with.
Common Reasons for Insurance Claim Denials
Common reasons include:
- Policy exclusions or limitations: The loss may be outside the events or circumstances to which the policy applies.
- Incorrect or incomplete information: Missing details or inaccurate information during the application or claims process can affect the outcome.
- Late claim notification: Delays in notifying the insurer may create difficulties, particularly if they affect its ability to investigate.
- Disagreements about damage or liability: The insurer may dispute the extent of the damage, the cause of the loss, or who is responsible.
- Alleged non-disclosure or policy breaches: An insurer may argue that relevant information was not disclosed or that a policy condition was not met.
Understanding the specific reason for rejection is the first step towards deciding whether a challenge is worthwhile.
What Should You Do If Your Insurance Claim Is Denied?
A rejection can seem final, especially if the insurer’s explanation is long or full of jargon. Still, it’s worth looking over the decision before you accept it.
- Review the Insurance Claim Rejection Letter
Read the letter very carefully and establish exactly why your claim has been refused. Check that the insurer has set out the evidence and the relevant policy provisions which form the basis of their decision. If the explanation is unclear, request in writing that they provide further details.
- Check Your Insurance Policy
Have a proper look at the relevant sections of your policy (including the PDS, the exclusions, the definitions and the conditions). Check that the insurer has applied those provisions to your situation correctly.
If you know your rights for home & property insurance, you may be better prepared to question an unclear or potentially incorrect decision.
- Gather Supporting Evidence
Collect photographs, invoices, repair estimates, expert reports, claim forms, and correspondence with the insurer. Keep copies of every document and create a timeline of events. If the insurer’s assessment appears inconsistent with the available evidence, an independent expert opinion may help clarify the dispute.
Avoid discarding damaged items before documenting them, where practical and safe to do so.
How to Dispute a Denied Insurance Claim in Queensland
If you think your claim was unfairly rejected, you can usually start by making a formal complaint to your insurer. If that doesn’t fix the problem, you might be able to take the dispute further.
- Submit an Internal Complaint to Your Insurer
Write to the insurer’s internal dispute resolution (IDR) team. Set out your reasons for disagreeing with the decision, reference the relevant policy terms and attach any supporting evidence. Be very clear about the outcome you are seeking (e.g. that the claim is reconsidered or that payment is made for the damage which is covered). Do keep a copy of your complaint and the insurer’s response.
- Escalate the Dispute to AFCA
If the matter isn’t resolved, then you may be able to complain to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). AFCA handles eligible complaints about insurance claim decisions and provides the service free of charge to consumers. It will assess the evidence and, where appropriate, issue a binding determination.
- Keep Records and Check Deadlines
Save all letters, emails, call notes, policy documents and expert reports. Check AFCA’s eligibility requirements and time limits as well as any time limits on legal proceedings. Don’t assume that making a complaint gives you the right to go to court at a later date.
What Are Your Legal Rights When an Insurance Claim Is Denied?
An insurer can’t just refuse a claim simply because they see things differently from you. Their decision has to follow your insurance contract and the law.
- Understanding the Insurance Contracts Act 1984
The Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) governs many Australian insurance contracts. It includes provisions concerning disclosure, good faith and the circumstances in which an insurer may reduce or refuse payment. The effect of these provisions depends on the policy and the facts of the dispute.
- Can an Insurer Legally Refuse to Pay a Claim?
Yes, an insurer may lawfully reject a claim where the policy and relevant law support that decision. However, a refusal may be challengeable if the insurer has misinterpreted an exclusion, overlooked evidence or incorrectly applied a policy condition. The outcome depends on the circumstances, including any applicable legal protections or defences.
When Should You Contact an Insurance Dispute Lawyer in Queensland?
Getting legal advice can help if the insurer’s decision is hard to understand or if a lot of money is at stake. Experienced insurance lawyers in Brisbane can review your policy, explain why your claim was rejected, and walk you through your options for resolving the dispute.
- Complex or High-Value Insurance Disputes
Consider getting advice if expert reports don’t agree, repair costs are high, the insurer alleges fraud or non-disclosure, or the policy wording is confusing. Getting advice early can help you see how strong your case is before you spend more time or money.
Conclusion: Understand Your Options After an Insurance Claim Denial
A denied claim isn’t always the end of the road. Review the insurer’s reasons, gather your evidence, and follow the right complaint steps. If you know your rights for home & property insurance, it can help you make better choices about challenging a refusal. Legal advice can also help you figure out your next move.
If negotiations and complaints don’t solve the problem, court may be an option. A lawyer can help you look at possible claims, deadlines, costs, and whether taking legal action makes sense for the amount involved.
Has your insurance claim been denied, or did your insurer offer less than you think your policy covers?
Cochrane Leahy provides practical advice on insurance disputes, from reviewing a refusal to assessing potential litigation. The team can help you understand your options, the risks involved, and the likely costs before deciding how to proceed. Call on 0421 608 459 to schedule a consultation to discuss your circumstances and explore a suitable path towards resolving your insurance dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions About Denied Insurance Claims
Can I challenge an insurance claim denial in Queensland?
Yes. You can request an internal review and, if eligible, escalate the dispute to AFCA. The strength of your challenge depends on the policy, evidence, and applicable law.
Is it free to complain to AFCA?
Yes. AFCA’s complaint service is free for consumers.
Can I sue an insurance company for refusing my claim?
Potentially. A lawyer can assess whether court proceedings are appropriate, considering the legal merits, costs, and deadlines.